There’s a perfect formula for everyone on this list, regardless of your priorities. We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. Why Trust Us? Picking out th...

There’s a perfect formula for everyone on this list, regardless of your priorities.
We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back. Why Trust Us?
Picking out the right products for a solid skincare routine is always a challenge, especially as we age. Products that once worked wonders for us may need to be considered as our skin changes and our priorities in taking care of it shift. While you might not actually need to devote an entire shelf of your medicine cabinet to countless serums and masks, there is one that experts agree goes a long way: a reliable eye cream for mature skin.
As we all know, the skin around our eyes requires a particularly delicate touch. It’s more prone to wrinkles, fine lines, puffiness, and loss of elasticity, which means it’s also the area that is often the first to show visible signs of aging. “The skin around the eye is known to sag, causing droopy eyelids as we age, and the circulation decreases. Many are prone to dark circles due to the skin being thin, thus more translucent,” says Dara Spearman, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist at Radiant Dermatology in Indiana.
The best eye creams for mature skin nourish the delicate area while getting to the root of those visible signs of aging. “A medical-grade eye cream can help boost collagen production, improve elasticity, and smooth fine lines,” says Kristin Gunn, B.S., C.L.T., L.M.A., celebrity aesthetician and owner of Halcyon Skincare and Beaux Medspa in Austin.
But the best eye cream for you will also vary based on your specific skin needs. That’s where we come in. We chatted with dermatologists to get their recommendations for eye creams suited to mature skin of all types. Whether you want to combat wrinkles, lighten dark spots, or focus on moisturizing, our experts have you covered. See the top picks below to help you maintain a smooth, even, and glowing complexion.
Our team consulted Kristin Gunn, B.S., C.L.T., L.M.A., a celebrity aesthetician and owner of Halcyon Skincare and Beaux Medspa in Austin; Dara Spearman, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist at Radiant Dermatology in Indiana; and Kristina Collins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist and Mohs micrographic surgeon at Austin Skin. We also conducted our own testing and evaluated customer reviews, ratings, and product specs to narrow down the best eye creams for mature skin for various needs and preferences.
Every single one of our experts recommended this pick as one of the best eye creams for mature skin for its skin barrier-supporting formula. “This one is a powerful treatment with peptides, antioxidants, and hydrating ingredients, as well as skin barrier support,” Gunn says of the cream. “It’s lightweight, ideal for all skin types and can be used both morning and night,” she adds. Dr. Collins found it to be effective in strengthening the skin barrier for firmer skin and increasing elasticity to help eliminate sagging and fine lines.
Both Dr. Spearman and Kristina Collins, M.D., F.A.A.D., a board-certified dermatologist and Mohs micrographic surgeon at Austin Skin, recommend this advanced eye cream from SkinCeuticals for its ability to combat fine lines. Collins says the magic of its abilities lies in the formula’s pro-xylene, which targets glycation—a major cause of aging—to restore elasticity. Dr. Spearman adds it also “has peptides which are great for firming the skin.”
Gunn calls this overnight cream “a fave for all skin types,” for its gentle but super-packed formula, chock-full of ingredients for nearly every under-eye concern in the book. “It blends a gentle retinoid with lactic acid to improve the appearance of fine lines, wrinkles, and skin texture,” she says. “EyeMax not only contains hydrating ingredients, antioxidants, and peptides but is also designed to address puffiness, dark circles, dryness, and crepiness. This one has it all.”
Finding retinol that is safe for sensitive skin isn’t always easy, but Dr. Collins has found it in this option from Murad. She recommends this “gentle, fast-acting retinol formula that minimizes irritation,” while still firming skin, reducing dark circles, and combating fine lines and puffed lids. And unlike many other formulas, this retinol is even safe to use on the thin skin of your eyelids.
This eye cream from La Roche-Posay is a crowd-pleaser for its ability to combat dark circles. Dr. Spearman comments she “love[s] this product because it contains caffeine and niacinamide, which are great for de-puffing the under-eye area.” Reviewers also love the applicator, which isn’t just easy to use but is also cooling, adding the benefit of depuffing, as well. But be warned, it might not be suitable for sensitive skin, as it does contain retinol, which may be drying for some.
Sagging and sunken eyes can benefit from a highly moisturizing formula, like this one from Biossance. Dr. Collins loves it because it is “lightweight but deeply nourishing for dry skin,” meaning that it likely won’t sit heavily on sensitive or oily skin, either. She also adds that it is excellent at “plumping fine lines” and doling out “deep hydration.”
If brightening your under eyes is your predominant concern, Dr. Spearman thinks this pick from Drunk Elephant is a “great product to brighten and firm the skin.” That’s mostly due to its vitamin C-forward formula, along with peptides and ceramides, which can help “combat discoloration and overall help with the appearance of the skin,” she tells us.
As someone who has dark circles and generally dull under-eye skin from a lack of sleep, I can attest to this cream’s brightening powers. I particularly enjoy putting it on under makeup and find that I actually need less concealer when I use it as my base.
Can’t splurge right now? Not a problem. Dr. Spearman loves this “budget-friendly option” for its key ingredients of hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and niacinamide—and so do over 66,000 reviewers on Amazon. The formula “helps restore and brighten the skin. This is a great product to add hydration, and if you suffer from dark circles,” she says.
“Dermatologists love this eye cream for mature skin because it uses growth factors and caffeine for deep skin repair,” Dr. Collins tells us of Neocutis’s science-backed, cutting-edge skincare. In addition to repairing the skin, it also features a potent combination of proprietary peptides, which help hydrate the skin and make it appear firmer, nearly instantly.
This is my favorite cream for the winter, as it not only helps protect the delicate under-eye area but also helps repair it when weather is its harshest and my skin feels extra dry and sensitive.
Dr. Spearman calls this retinol cream “a great product for those with more mature skin,” as it contains retinol and is known to smooth skin overnight. In addition to being “great for wrinkles and anti-aging,” she says it is also very affordable. While many retinol creams can be irritating to the sensitive eye skin, reviewers agree that the hydration from niacinamide and vitamin E in the formula soothes it instantly—and reportedly lasts up to 24 hours.
Gunn explains that not all of the best eye creams for mature skin are expensive. “Mario Badescu has great budget-friendly eye creams, with ingredients specific to whatever your skin needs,” she says—and her favorite is this one, which is highly moisturizing. “It’s lightweight, and the rich hyaluronic acid it contains will keep the skin around your eyes soft, smooth, and hydrated. It’s ideal for those looking to address dryness and fine lines caused by dehydration.”
If you are looking for an eye cream for mature skin that also doubles as a concealer and an SPF, no, it’s not too good to be true. Dr. Collins loves this formula from Colorescience for its combination of “brightening, hydration, and SPF in one.” We all know that sun protection is essential, but having one that can also combat dark circles and puffiness sounds good to us. Available in four shades, it also layers well with makeup for those who prefer more coverage.
This Neutrogena serum is aimed at fighting wrinkles. It claims to improve fine lines in just one week of daily use, thanks to the ingredient retinol. Prevention’s former digital director Allie Early called this product "moisturizing and affordable for the amount of benefits it offers," while noting that a little bit goes a long way. Retinol doesn't always play nice with sensitive skin, but for those who tolerate it, the lightweight, silky formula can be a great addition to your skincare routine.
✔️ Prioritize moisture. When it comes to choosing a formula, different ingredients have different benefits, but all our experts agree that hydration is key. “Most of us need hydration for smoothing fine lines, which means ingredients like hyaluronic acid and glycerin help draw moisture into the delicate skin around the eyes.”
✔️ Look for ingredients tailored to your needs. Depending on your major concerns, you are going to need different ingredients (see more on that below).
✔️ Apply gently. “Be careful when applying skincare products or makeup to this sensitive area; never tug or pull the skin as it can increase risk for damage,” says Dr. Spearman. “Use your ring finger to apply the least pressure. Apply a pea-size amount of product and gently pat the product around the eye area.”
✔️ Prevent under eyes from further damage with protective measures like SPF. “I recommend wearing a moisturizer with broad-spectrum SPF daily to protect the skin around the eyes,” explains Dr. Spearman. “I also recommend wearing sunglasses especially if you are planning on being out in the sun for long periods of time,” she adds. Plus, getting enough sleep and hydrating can also help avoid puffiness and dark circles.
Retinol stimulates collagen production to help smooth fine lines and wrinkles, she says of those who want to focus primarily on anti-aging benefits.
Peptides and ceramides primarily strengthen the skin barrier.
Caffeine reduces puffiness by constricting blood vessels and helps reduce the appearance of under-eye bags.
Vitamin C brightens dark circles and boosts collagen.
Niacinamide and licorice extract work to even skin tone, reduce discoloration, and soothe irritated or sensitive skin.
Charlotte Lewis Finigan is the Senior Commerce Editor at Prevention. After a decade of working in Hollywood writers’ rooms and contributing pop culture writing to ETOnline, Bustle, TVGuide, and CBS, she underwent bariatric surgery and changed her focus to health and wellness. Previously, Charlotte was the Sexual Health & Wellness Writer for Refinery 29. There, she wrote and edited shopping content about new wellness trends, beauty launches, and sex-positive products. She currently lives in Brooklyn with her girlfriend—and the love of her life, her senior dog, Rory. All three can typically be found perusing the Fort Green farmer’s market for fresh produce or curling up on the couch to watch Survivor.
We may earn commission from links on this page, but we only recommend products we back.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.